> ## Content Index
> Fetch the complete content index at: https://www.ardmt.com/llms.txt
> Use this file to discover other available public pages before exploring further.

# We All Eat Hummus
- URL: https://www.ardmt.com/we-all-eat-hummus/
- Published: 2026-10-25T09:11:00.000Z
- Updated: 2026-10-25T09:10:59.000Z
- Description: A study of mixed ayahuasca circles in Israel found the oneness was easy. The moments that mattered were the ones that broke it.
- Author: Stephen Page
- Tags: Ethics, MSc Notes

What happens when Israelis and Palestinians drink ayahuasca together, and then go home?  
*A study of mixed ayahuasca circles in Israel found the oneness was easy. The moments that mattered were the ones that broke it.*

**In short**

- For about ten years, small groups of Israelis and Palestinians have drunk ayahuasca together. The Palestinians were almost always the minority, and the ceremonies were mostly run by Israelis.
- The feeling that "we are all one" was common. But it could paper over the huge inequality between the two sides. The moments that mattered were the ones when that inequality came out into the open.
- When the night was over, the two sides went home to very different lives. Since October 2023, many in one group have scattered, left or gone quiet.

## The house

Ayahuasca is a brew from the Amazon that causes powerful visions. It is usually drunk at night, in a group, with a leader who sings. In Israel it is illegal, so these ceremonies were held in secret.

One night, a Palestinian man drank it in a house in a Jewish town in northern Israel. The house once belonged to an Arab family who were forced to flee in the 1948 war. Today a religious Jewish family lives there. The songs in the ceremony were in Hebrew.

He went outside and sat under a vine that reminded him of his grandfather's. There, he says, he saw the house's former owners. He came back inside angry and started singing in Arabic to break up the ceremony. The leader sat him down and sang a song by Fairuz, the much-loved Lebanese singer. Soon, he says, "everybody gets up and is dancing and hugging."

It's a moving ending. But the more interesting question is why he was in that room at all. The house had been lost by people like him. The ceremony was run by Israelis, in Hebrew. And when it ended, he walked back out into the same country, under the same rules.

Leor Roseman, an Israeli psychedelics researcher now at the University of Exeter, interviewed 31 people who took part in ceremonies like this one. His team published two papers in 2021\. A podcast, *Altered States*, later followed people from a retreat he helped run in 2022\. Together, they tell a story about who holds the power.

![A man holds coffee beside a window as golden psychedelic visions surround him. Outside, people queue at a checkpoint beneath a concrete wall.](https://storage.ghost.io/c/fd/26/fd26d717-b634-4499-816e-3108a3b6e35c/content/images/2026/10/Halo-in-the-Kitchen-Window.png)

The vision is total; the integration is negotiable. Revelation becomes self-acceptance, while the wall outside remains.

## Who holds the power

A ceremony like this happens in a circle, and a circle looks equal. These ones weren't.

Inside the room:

- Palestinians were usually no more than one in five of the people there.
- Most of the talking and singing was in Hebrew.
- The people running the ceremonies were mostly Jewish Israelis, who also had more experience with ayahuasca.

That matters, because on ayahuasca you are at your most vulnerable. In the researchers' words, the Palestinians "relied on the support and guidance of Jewish-Israelis."

Outside the room, the gap is far bigger. A few of the Palestinians lived in the West Bank, under Israeli military rule. The rest were Palestinian citizens of Israel, who often face discrimination there. The Israelis were citizens of the state that runs the army, and military service is compulsory for most Jewish Israelis.

To give a sense of what that means: the Palestinian psychiatrist Samah Jabr and a colleague write that about one in three Palestinian men has been detained by the Israeli military at some point since the 1960s, often without charge. Children are sometimes taken from their beds in the middle of the night.

One Israeli man in the study had carried out exactly that kind of night arrest as a soldier. During a ceremony he relived it, but this time from the family's side:

> "I saw myself arresting the guy, leaving, and the door closes, and I stay with them, a broken family whose world has just been destroyed… my eyes in that ski mask might be carved for life in their minds as the eyes of the guy who ruined their life, and it undid me."

Even the risk of turning up wasn't equal. The ceremonies were illegal, and the legal risks were highest for Palestinians. People from the West Bank had to cross Israeli checkpoints to get there. One Palestinian woman would only be named by a pseudonym, because drinking ayahuasca goes against her religion and community.

And the fear doesn't always switch off when the drug takes hold. Nadeem Karkabi, an anthropologist who studies Palestinian rave parties, describes a Palestinian man who had a bad trip at an Israeli party. He saw the dancers around him in army uniforms, carrying guns, coming to hurt him. Psychedelics turn up the volume on whatever is in the room. Sometimes what's in the room is the army.

## Why go at all?

So why would someone on the weaker side open themselves up, on a powerful drug, to people from the stronger side? The people involved give several answers.

**To stop being afraid.** Sami Awad, a Palestinian peace activist who began drinking ayahuasca with Israelis around 2012, tells a story from when he was 12\. He was planting trees with his uncle on a farmer's land that settlers wanted. A soldier pulled up his tree and threw it on the rocks. He picked it up and planted it again. "That sense of feeling, wow, empowerment. And then losing the fear." For him, sitting in the circle is the same kind of act.

**To be seen.** Mariam, a Palestinian Bedouin woman, grew up in Israel being called a terrorist at school. After a retreat, she described the group as a place where "you've always been seen in the best light you can be seen at."

**To gain respect.** Palestinians who sang their own songs in ceremony, and were listened to, often went on to help lead later ceremonies. The room shifted a little in their favour.

**To get a break from being "the Palestinian".** In Karkabi's research, a Palestinian woman, Siwar (a pseudonym), described taking a strong psychedelic and forgetting she was Palestinian, or even that she lived in Israel. She loved it. A friend asked: "Isn't this exactly what the Israelis want?" She snapped back that she was sick of having to answer for her whole nation. Both of them had a point.

Rachel Yehuda, a leading trauma researcher, called the whole project "a fantasy, it's a wish, and yet it's probably worth trying." The real magic, she said, wasn't the brew: "It's the fact that you wanted to do this."

It would be wrong, though, to picture the Palestinians as passive. In these accounts they interrupt ceremonies, sing over the Hebrew prayers, and sometimes start ceremonies of their own. After October 2023, Awad led one for Palestinians only. Being the weaker side in the room is not the same as being powerless.

## Three kinds of moment

The researchers sorted what people described into three kinds of moment. Each deals with the power gap differently.

1. **"We are all one."** 18 of the 31 people interviewed described feeling that labels like Jewish, Arab, Israeli and Palestinian simply melted away.
2. **Being heard as different.** 21 of 31 described moments when the other side's culture really got through to them. For example, a Hebrew-speaking room falling silent when someone sang in Arabic.
3. **Painful visions about the conflict.** 15 of 31 had at least one vision about the conflict, such as the families who fled in 1948, or blood soaking the land. These were rare: once or twice over dozens of ceremonies.

**The first is the one people celebrate, and the one the researchers trust least.** Roseman puts it bluntly on the podcast: "We're all eat hummus. We all in the oneness of the medicine. But you know, you dilute the political anger." Psychologists have found the same thing in ordinary peace programmes. Warm feelings between groups can leave the weaker group expecting a fairness that never arrives. A good night can let off steam and leave everything as it was.

**The second is more promising.** It doesn't pretend everyone is the same. It was also slow. Several Israelis said that hearing Arabic sung in ceremony at first made them afraid or angry, before something shifted.

**The third is where the power gap shows itself.** A Palestinian man from the West Bank found himself, in a vision, inside the body of an Israeli soldier pulling a trigger. He came out of it feeling sorry for the soldier: "this is not an easy life after."

That may be the most unsettling thing in the whole study: the weaker side ending up comforting the stronger. One scene makes it plain. A group of Palestinians cried together with an Israeli friend who was working through trauma from his army service. They cried "ambivalently", the paper notes, because they knew about his time in the army.

Is that kindness, or one more thing asked of the people who already carry the most? The ceremony can't answer that for them.

## Coming down

Psychedelic culture talks a lot about "integration": making sense of a trip in the days afterwards. It assumes you go home to somewhere safe enough to do that. For the Palestinians in these groups, that isn't true.

Samah Jabr argues that Palestinians don't really have post-traumatic stress, because there is no "post". The trauma isn't over; it's ongoing. PTSD, she says, describes a soldier who goes home after a war, but "in Palestine, the loop is reality." She calls trauma "the disaster of helplessness." A ceremony can lift that helplessness for a night. In the morning, the checkpoint is still there.

The Israelis found coming home hard too. Rotem, who went on the 2022 retreat in Spain, said: "I felt like so much unity in Spain… but suddenly you come back here and you are again separated… you don't have agency over the reality."

But the two homecomings aren't the same. The former soldier who saw his own masked eyes through a Palestinian family's eyes woke up to his own part in the system. That is painful, but he gets to choose what to do with it. The researchers' follow-up suggests at least one Israeli participant later softened his vision into a lesson about accepting himself. The Palestinian wakes up to the conditions themselves. Jabr is blunt about comparing the two: there is "no equivalence possible between the suffering of the colonized and the suffering of settlers."

Research on people who struggled after taking psychedelics backs up the worry, up to a point. A survey of 608 such people found that feeling cut off from others was among the most common problems, and about a third were still struggling more than a year later. But that study was about personal fallout. No one has yet studied what it's like to come down from "we are all one" into a military occupation.

## After October 7

On 7 October 2023, Hamas attacked Israel, killing around 1,200 people. Israel's war on Gaza followed, killing tens of thousands of Palestinians.

The 31 people in the 2021 study were never named. But the podcast *Altered States* followed people from Roseman and Awad's 2022 retreat in Spain, where 15 Israelis and 18 Palestinians drank ayahuasca together. Here is where some of them were when the podcast last caught up with them, around mid-2024.

| Who                                             | What happened                                                                                                       | In their words                                                             |
| ----------------------------------------------- | ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | -------------------------------------------------------------------------- |
| Liel, Israeli                                   | A student of his was killed at the Nova music festival on October 7\. He later left Israel for Brazil               | "I'm really in a point of like this region is rotten"                      |
| Mariam (not her real name), Palestinian, Israel | Had planned to start a political art magazine. Since October 7 she has withdrawn and hasn't had the energy to talk  | Before: "normal in a very radical way"                                     |
| Souli, Palestinian, near Jerusalem              | Sent a message a week after the attack calling for love and forgiveness. Later spoke on tours in the US and Germany | "Some people go back to their tribe right now… because they can't take it" |
| Rotem, Israeli                                  | Joined protests at the Gaza border, trying to get food trucks past settlers blocking the road                       | "How can you stay sane when people don't have food?"                       |
| Sharon, Israeli                                 | Still in the group, but has fallen out with a Palestinian friend                                                    | "We don't really talk now. It's very lonely"                               |
| Sami Awad, Palestinian organiser                | Still running the group, mostly online because checkpoints were closed. Led a ceremony for Palestinians only        | "There isn't this absolute healing from trauma"                            |

Sharon's story is where the power gap breaks the surface. A few days after the attack, his Palestinian friend told him that "every resistance is legitimate." Sharon said he understood the power dynamics. But he asked for the seven days of mourning, called shiva, that Jewish tradition gives to the dead. They don't really talk now.

Jabr would say that putting Israeli grief alongside Palestinian suffering creates a false balance. For Sharon, it was simply a request to grieve. Friendship across the divide is possible. It doesn't make the two sides equal, and when the violence came, that inequality shaped what each felt able to say.

Roseman's own verdict is honest about the cost. "Something really worked," he said: the group's old us-versus-them reflexes didn't kick in as easily. "But it also means… that it's hard for them." People who no longer fit their own side's story have nowhere comfortable to stand.

The Spain study itself hadn't been published when the podcast aired. Roseman still presents the work, most recently in June 2026\. 

## What we can and can't conclude

This research tells us about people's experiences. It doesn't prove results. The 2021 study was based on interviews after the fact, with no comparison group. The people who agreed to talk were mostly comfortable, middle-class and into alternative spirituality. The groups deliberately kept politics out of the ceremonies. The 2022 retreat found people felt very close to each other while it lasted, but that says nothing about what happened afterwards. And the podcast is journalism about a handful of people.

Ayahuasca isn't a peace drug, either. Awad is blunt: "Ayahuasca is not a peace medicine or a love medicine." There are settlers near his home, he says, who drink it "to receive confirmation from God that this is their land." The brew amplifies whatever intentions people bring with them, including the occupation's.

## The checkpoint is still there

The power gap isn't a flaw in these ceremonies that better organisation could fix. It's the reason they matter. "We are all one" between equals is a nice evening. Between a man whose people lost that house and the family living in it now, it is either a first step towards something or a painkiller. The ceremony alone can't tell you which.

What the research does show is this. When the room let people be heard as different, some Israelis glimpsed what they were part of, and some Palestinians gained respect. When the room insisted on harmony, it asked the people with the least to carry the most.

Then everyone went home, and home wasn't the same place for each of them. The real test isn't the hug at dawn. It's what the person with the power does the morning after, and whether the person without it is any safer for having trusted them.

## Sources

- Roseman L, Ron Y, Saca A, Ginsberg N, Luan L, Karkabi N, Doblin R, Carhart-Harris R (2021). [Relational Processes in Ayahuasca Groups of Palestinians and Israelis](https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fphar.2021.607529/full?ref=ardmt.com). *Frontiers in Pharmacology* 12:607529.
- Roseman L, Karkabi N (2021). [On Revelations and Revolutions: Drinking Ayahuasca Among Palestinians Under Israeli Occupation](https://www.frontiersin.org/journals/psychology/articles/10.3389/fpsyg.2021.718934?ref=ardmt.com). *Frontiers in Psychology* 12:718934.
- Shealy S (2024). [The Peace Seekers](https://psychedelics.berkeley.edu/altered-states-peace-seekers?ref=ardmt.com). *Altered States*, UC Berkeley Center for the Science of Psychedelics and PRX. Rebroadcast as [Tim Ferriss Show #768](https://tim.blog/2024/09/18/what-happens-when-israelis-and-palestinians-drink-ayahuasca-together/?ref=ardmt.com).
- Karkabi N (2020). [Self-Liberated Citizens: Unproductive Pleasures, Loss of Self, and Playful Subjectivities in Palestinian Raves](https://doi.org/10.1353/anq.2020.0071?ref=ardmt.com). *Anthropological Quarterly* 93(4), 679–708.
- Jabr S, Haddadi A (2026). [Genocidal politics of settler psychopathology and Palestinian liberation as healthy becoming: an interview with Dr Samah Jabr](https://doi.org/10.1080/1369801X.2026.2681430?ref=ardmt.com). *Interventions*.
- Jabr S, Helbich M (2025). [Torture as a tool of domination: the logic behind the use of torture against Palestinians](https://doi.org/10.7146/torture.v35i2.156977?ref=ardmt.com). *Torture* 35(2–3), 101–111.
- Jabr S, Berger E. War, Trauma, and the Survival of Hope in Palestine: What We Learn from its Children. In Fiorella K (ed.), *Child and Adolescent Psychoanalysis in Times of Crisis*. Routledge.
- [‘Chronic traumatic stress disorder’: the Palestinian psychologist challenging western definitions of trauma](https://uk.news.yahoo.com/ve-seen-bombs-deaths-bodies-040041501.html?ref=ardmt.com), *The Guardian* (via Yahoo)
- Evans J et al. (2023). [Extended difficulties following the use of psychedelic drugs: a mixed methods study](https://gala.gre.ac.uk/id/eprint/44668?ref=ardmt.com). *PLOS ONE* 18(10): e0293349.
- [The Israelis and Palestinians Doing Ayahuasca Together](https://www.vice.com/en/article/israeli-palestinian-ayahuasca-ceremony/?ref=ardmt.com), VICE
- [Ripples: Psychedelic Peacebuilding and Collective Liberation in Palestine and Israel](https://www.aspenpublicradio.org/ideas-speakers-lectures/2026-06-21/aps2026-leor-roseman-phd-ripples-psychedelic-peacebuilding-and-collective-liberation-in-palestine-and-israel?ref=ardmt.com), Aspen Public Radio (June 2026)
- Saguy T, Tausch N, Dovidio JF, Pratto F (2009). The irony of harmony. *Psychological Science* 20, 114–121.